10 Analytics Tools for Identifying the Source of Your Highest-Converting Traffic

Uncover the secrets to boosting conversion rates with state-of-the-art analytics tools, as top industry experts share their invaluable perspectives. This article delves into the most effective strategies to pinpoint where the most valuable traffic originates, guided by insights from leaders in data analysis. Empower business decisions with expert-backed approaches to identifying and leveraging high-converting traffic sources.

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!

Identify High-Converting Traffic with UTM and GTM

I find that using UTM parameters with Google Tag Manager (GTM) is one of the best ways to identify the source of my highest-converting traffic. UTM parameters are simple tags you add to your links to track exactly where your traffic is coming from—like a Facebook ad, an email newsletter, or a specific blog post. GTM makes it easy to manage these tagged links and monitor user behavior on your site, from landing to conversion.

What’s great is that GTM isn’t limited to UTM tracking. For e-commerce use cases for example, you can incorporate custom events to track actions like product views, add-to-carts, and purchases. These custom events give you deeper insights into how traffic sources contribute to on-site behaviors and revenue. This setup is precise and customizable, perfect for understanding the full picture of what drives results. It takes about 2–3 hours to set up.

Joe McHugh, Marketing for Professional Photographers, Wedding Photographer Sites

Woopra Provides Unique Customer-Centric Insights

While tools like Google Analytics dominate the conversation, one analytics platform I’ve found incredibly insightful is Woopra. It’s often overlooked, but its customer-centric approach provides a unique perspective on traffic and conversions.

Woopra stands out because it bridges the gap in web analytics and user-level data for your whole tech stack, from CRM, email platforms, to even customer support. It goes the extra mile to show not just where the traffic is coming from but how individual users interact across multiple touchpoints before converting.

For example, we used Woopra to understand that our best-converting traffic wasn’t just from organic search but really from visitors that viewed a pricing page and an educational blog post in the same session. That granularity of insight enabled us to fine-tune our content strategy and better optimize our landing pages for that audience.

Reilly James Renwick, Chief Marketing Officer, Pragmatic Mortgage Lending

WhatConverts Tracks Interactions to Real Leads

The analytics tool we rely on to identify the source of our highest-converting traffic is WhatConverts. It’s incredibly effective because it doesn’t just track clicks; it connects those interactions to real leads and sales, giving us a complete view of the customer journey. With WhatConverts, we can see which channels, campaigns, and even specific keywords drive the most valuable conversions. This level of detail helps us make data-driven decisions to allocate resources where they’ll have the greatest impact. We prefer it because it simplifies tracking across multiple touchpoints—like calls, forms, and chats—into one platform, making it easy to show clear ROI to our clients and refine strategies for even better results.

John Leutermann, Owner, Big Rock Marketing

SEMrush Compares Traffic Sources to Competitors

SEMrush Traffic Analytics provides a unique perspective by comparing our traffic sources to competitors’. In one campaign, we noticed competitors relied heavily on paid traffic while our organic content dominated conversions. This motivated us to allocate more resources to high-performing blog content.

Shane McEvoy, MD, Flycast Media

Kissmetrics Tracks Customer Journey from First Touch

We use Kissmetrics to identify the source of our highest-converting traffic. It gives us deep insights into customer behavior, allowing us to track the journey from first touch to conversion. Kissmetrics’ event tracking and customer segmentation features are particularly useful in understanding how different sources, such as organic search, paid ads, or influencer partnerships, contribute to sales.

I prefer Kissmetrics because it goes beyond surface-level traffic data and helps us understand the full customer lifecycle. We can track how visitors interact with our site, what products they’re interested in, and where they drop off in the purchasing process. This allows us to make informed decisions on how to optimize each traffic source for maximum conversions. It also helps us align our marketing efforts with our brand’s values, ensuring that we’re targeting the right audience in the right way.

Jehann Biggs, President & Owner, In2Green

Mixpanel Pinpoints High-Converting Visitors’ Origin

For fintech companies in particular, Mixpanel is a powerful analytics tool for pinpointing the origin of our highest-converting visitors. Through tools like group analysis and retention analytics, its event-based tracking gives firms comprehensive insights and enables them to map the complete customer journey, from acquisition to conversion. When paired with its funnel analysis, Mixpanel’s ability to assign conversions to particular sources aids in identifying the most efficient traffic channels. 

A digital-only bank often uses Mixpanel to examine user behavior and found that the most loan application completions came from visitors from their affiliate marketing program. They redesigned their incentives to improve performance after identifying the exact affiliates generating the conversions through in-depth analysis of the data. By concentrating on the best-performing sources, this approach decreased acquisition expenses while increasing their loan conversion rate by 18% over a six-month period.

Dr. Manash Sarkar, Expert Data Scientist, Limendo GmbH

Hotjar Analyzes User Behavior for Conversions

Hotjar offers deep insights that other tools often miss, such as during heat mapping for example. For example, while launching a particular campaign some time ago, I observed that a particular landing page was yielding an abnormally high degree of conversion. In Google Analytics, for instance, the source of the traffic is available, but it does not explain to you why this page was so good. Hotjar was able to close this gap. 

With the aid of its heatmaps, I noticed that a certain section of the page—to be specific, a bold testimonial slider located right above the fold—drew a lot of attention from the visitors. It also backs my deductions considering that social proof translates into conversions. I was able to increase conversion rates on these pages by an average of 20% by implementing this same layout on other pages and watching their heat maps. 

The most identifying characteristic of Hotjar is the type of data that it helps you analyze: user behavior. It converts raw data into tangible insights. Understanding what users click, scroll, or other types of off points leads to accurate optimization. Even though traffic sources are important, the reason behind the conversion is more important. 

This method has enabled me to consider tools that provide me not only with what I need but also with why it is necessary. I’ll advise pairing traffic estimates with behavioral tools like Hotjar for businesses that wish to polish their user flow and make the most of their investment. Because in my opinion, this is more than simply about the source of visitors, it is about how to enhance engagement with them.

Soubhik Chakrabarti, CEO, Icy Tales

GA4 Offers Granular Insights and Attribution

While many analytics platforms offer basic traffic source data, Google Analytics 4 (GA4) stands out for its granular insights and advanced attribution modeling capabilities. It’s become our go-to tool for identifying where our highest-converting traffic originates and how different marketing channels interact throughout the customer journey. This nuanced understanding allows us to allocate resources and fine-tune campaigns strategically for maximum impact.

GA4’s strength lies in its event-based data model. Unlike its predecessor, Universal Analytics, GA4 doesn’t rely solely on sessions. This ability allows for a more comprehensive view of user behavior across different devices and platforms, painting a clearer picture of the complete customer lifecycle. For instance, we can track a customer’s initial interaction with our blog post through organic search, engagement with our social media campaign, and conversion through a paid advertisement. This cross-channel visibility is invaluable in understanding the complex interplay of our marketing efforts.

The platform’s free, built-in attribution models are a game-changer. Rather than defaulting to the last-click attribution model, which often misrepresents the contribution of earlier touchpoints, GA4 offers data-driven attribution. This model uses machine learning to distribute credit across all contributing marketing channels, revealing the actual influence of each interaction leading up to a conversion. We’ve found this particularly helpful in understanding the role of content marketing in driving conversions. While content might not be the final touchpoint, data-driven attribution reveals its significance in nurturing leads and influencing later purchase decisions.

Beyond attribution modeling, GA4’s exploration reports provide a powerful workspace for custom analysis. We can segment our audience based on various dimensions, like acquisition source, demographics, and user behavior. This segmentation allows us to pinpoint the characteristics of our highest-converting traffic segments, revealing invaluable insights. For example, organic traffic from specific industry blogs converts significantly more than traffic from generic search queries. This knowledge then informs our content strategy, enabling us to target those high-performing niches with tailored content.

Steve Fleurant, CEO, Clair Services

Clicky Simplifies Customer Journey Tracking

I know that its heyday was years ago, but I still use Clicky. I love its simplicity and the fact that it just works. I think it’s so much easier to use than Google Analytics because you don’t have to waste time trying to find the right reports to run or where your data might be hiding. For $10/month, I can easily see customer journeys, including where they came from, to know which traffic sources are worth putting more focus and ad spend towards. I know there are more sophisticated tools out there, but when you’re bootstrapping, the basics are all you need and that’s what you get with Clicky.

Caspar Von Wrede, CEO & Founder, Keep The Score

Google Analytics and Looker Studio for Analysis

As a data analyst, I typically use a mix of Google Analytics and Looker Studio/Power BI.

I use Google Analytics as the data source for my analysis. It tells me how many users came to my website, where they came from and whether they converted or not. However, it is not possible to create the charts that I need inside of Google Analytics.

This is where Looker Studio/Power BI comes in. I use the native integration with GA4 that these tools have to extract the data. I would then build my own graphs inside of Looker Studio/Power BI to find the source and medium of converting traffic.

Eugene Lebedev, Managing Director, Vidi Corp LTD

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!