Exploring alternatives to traditional membership programs for fostering customer loyalty, we’ve gathered insights from six industry experts, including founders and CEOs. From the immediate appeal of surprise discounts and personalized gifts to the long-term engagement of a points-based system for interactive loyalty, these leaders offer a range of strategies to keep customers coming back.

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!

Contents

1 Surprise Discounts and Personalized Gifts
2 Cultivate Community for Customer Loyalty
3 Referral Incentives and Exceptional Service
4 Customized Rewards Strengthen Brand Bonds
5 Exclusive Early Access Enhances Experience
6 Points-Based System for Interactive Loyalty

Surprise Discounts and Personalized Gifts

As an e-commerce expert, I’ve found that surprise discounts and upgrades are highly effective for building customer loyalty without a formal membership program. We periodically offer mystery coupon codes that unlock 30-50% off to random customers at checkout. The thrill of discovering an unexpected deal keeps customers engaged and coming back.

For our VIP customers, we provide surprise add-on products with their orders. If someone spends over $200, we may include a free signature-scented candle or luxury bath product as a thank you. These thoughtful gifts make a personal connection and turn purchasers into enthusiastic brand ambassadors.

Data-driven personalization is another alternative we employ. By tracking individual purchase history and preferences, we tailor the shopping experience for each customer. Big spenders get first access to limited collections. People who favor certain styles or materials receive customized product recommendations and exclusive previews of items we think they’ll love.

Building genuine relationships and showing real appreciation for customers are far more effective ways to earn loyalty than any points or membership model alone. Thoughtful personalization and unexpected delights create emotional connections that keep people passionately engaged with your brand.

Steve Pogson, Founder, First Pier

Cultivate Community for Customer Loyalty

Membership programs can be effective, but they don’t always apply naturally to businesses outside of e-commerce and retail. With our business, we prioritize community building. We aim to cultivate loyal customers through creating platforms that encourage knowledge sharing. We partner with local marketing agencies for events to help our customers learn and grow their businesses. By going this route, we’re able to foster a similar sense of community and provide value to our customers beyond our products and services.

Chris Hunter, Director of Customer Relations, ServiceTitan

Referral Incentives and Exceptional Service

As an alternative to membership programs, I’d focus on referral incentives. At my startup, referrals have been critical for finding new clients. We offer $500 referral bonuses for any new schools that sign up. This has worked so well that over 50% of our new business now comes from referrals.

We also emphasize exceptional customer service. Our team provides “white glove” support 24/7 via live chat, email, or phone. We push software updates every week based on customer feedback to ensure the platform is easy to use. This dedication to customer happiness has given us a competitive advantage and high retention rates.

Finally, we don’t charge any setup fees and offer month-to-month contracts. This allows schools to try our solutions risk-free. Once they see the impact interactive displays and digital yearbooks have on engagement, they become long-term clients. Keeping the buying process simple has accelerated our growth.

Our success with referrals, customer service, and flexible pricing shows there are many alternatives to membership programs for building loyalty. The key is choosing strategies aligned with your company values that genuinely benefit your clients.

Chase Mckee, Founder & CEO, Rocket Alumni Solutions

Customized Rewards Strengthen Brand Bonds

Customized rewards based on customer actions and likes appear to be a successful option for gathering client loyalty, in contrast with traditional membership programs.

Companies can utilize data analysis to offer personalized discounts, special promotions, or advance access to new items tailored to individual customer preferences.

By doing so, we don’t just improve the shopping experience. Actually, we believe that personalized rewards help to strengthen the emotional bond people have with the brand.

More than ever, we’re convinced that these are making people feel like they are part of the family, demonstrating to each customer that they are important and appreciated!

In the end, simply by showing gratitude, we get to increase loyalty to our brands, promote repeat buying, and generate favorable word-of-mouth, ultimately leading to lasting customer contentment.

Gabriel Kaam, CEO, KNR Agency

Exclusive Early Access Enhances Experience

One specific alternative to traditional membership programs for customer loyalty that has worked for me is offering exclusive early access to sales and new products. As a CEO, I believe this strategy not only enhances the customer experience but also cultivates and improves a sense of belonging among loyal customers.

By prioritizing our most engaged customers and providing them with unique opportunities, we can build deeper connections without relying solely on discounts. This approach encourages customers to feel valued and appreciated. It also leads to increased repeat business. Additionally, it can generate buzz and excitement around our brand, ultimately driving and boosting sales while maintaining healthy profit margins.

Kartik Ahuja, Digital Marketer, kartikahuja.com

Points-Based System for Interactive Loyalty

Another effective alternative to membership programs for customer loyalty is a points-based system tied to specific actions or behaviors that benefit both the customer and the company. Examples include rewarding customers for referrals, social media engagement, or completing surveys. This approach encourages desired customer behaviors by gamifying the loyalty experience, making it more interactive and enjoyable for customers. It avoids the potential drawbacks of traditional memberships, such as exclusivity, while building long-term customer relationships and brand advocacy.