7 Alternatives to Social Proof Widgets for Credibility

In the digital age, establishing credibility online is crucial, but social proof widgets aren’t the only way to do it. We’ve gathered seven expert opinions, including those from CEOs and a digital marketer, to explore alternatives. From highlighting quantitative experience metrics to employing TrustPulse notifications, discover a range of strategies that can enhance your website’s trustworthiness.

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!

Highlight Quantitative Experience Metrics

One specific alternative to social proof that I’ve seen be very effective in marketing is quantitative information—like cold, hard numbers! You can display how many years of experience you have, how many clients you’ve had, projects you’ve worked on, how much ad spend you’ve managed, etc. You could even talk about the education you’ve received or any certifications you have! In fact, depending on your audience, this type of information can even be seen as more credible than social proof or testimonials.

Joshua Hill, Brand Designer & Strategist, Green Tree Studio

Showcase Video Testimonials

Using video testimonials from satisfied customers can significantly enhance your social proof. Videos add a personal and authentic touch, showing real people sharing their positive experiences.

This format is more engaging and convincing than written testimonials because it captures genuine emotions and expressions. Potential customers can see and hear the enthusiasm of others, which builds trust and credibility in a more impactful way.

Video testimonials create a relatable connection, making it easier for new customers to envision themselves benefiting from your product or service.

Matias Rodsevich, Founder & CEO, PRLab

Present Detailed Case Studies

A well-done case study is highly impactful for credibility. It’s tangible proof that you’ve helped a client achieve a great result and how you did it. Include an overview of their business, where they were before you started, the approach you applied, and the outcomes they received from your methods. Include statistics, a testimonial, and showcase how you were uniquely positioned to help them achieve a specific result.

Amanda Hamilton, Website & SEO Specialist, Anchor ‹A› Digital Design Co.

Feature User-Generated Content

User-generated content (UGC) is a powerful alternative to social-proof widgets for building credibility. UGC includes reviews, testimonials, photos, and videos created by your customers. This content is authentic because it’s from real users sharing their genuine experiences. 

For example, if customers post photos of your products on social media, it builds community and trust. Highlighting these posts on your website or social media shows potential customers how others benefit from your products or services, adding authenticity that traditional marketing can’t match.

UGC also boosts engagement. Customers seeing content from their peers are more likely to relate and feel confident in their decisions. For instance, a digital agency can feature client success stories to validate its expertise and encourage others to share their positive experiences, making your brand more relatable and credible.

Shane McEvoy, MD, Flycast Media

Utilize Media Appearances

We leverage media appearances and speaking engagements as a way to build credibility. By participating in webinars, podcasts, and panels, and speaking at industry conferences, we can communicate our expertise directly to an engaged audience. These appearances provide a platform to discuss industry trends, showcase our knowledge, and put a human face on our brand, all of which contribute to strengthening our credibility in the digital marketing landscape.

Jason Hennessey, CEO, Hennessey Digital

Offer Transparent Customer Feedback

Implementing a transparent customer-feedback system is a robust alternative. Unlike traditional social-proof widgets that only show positive reviews, a transparent feedback system includes all customer opinions, good and bad. This openness not only builds trust but also demonstrates our commitment to continuous improvement and customer satisfaction. 

We make it a point to respond to all feedback publicly, addressing concerns and thanking customers for their praise. This approach not only improves our services but also solidifies our reputation as a client-focused company.

Marc Bishop, Director, Wytlabs

Employ TrustPulse Notifications

I’ve found that TrustPulse is an excellent alternative to social proof widgets like Proof. TrustPulse allows me to create and display real-time notifications about customer activity on my site, which helps build trust and credibility with new visitors. 

Compared to Proof, TrustPulse is much more affordable, with plans starting at just $5/month. Plus, it’s incredibly easy to set up and customize the notifications to match my brand. 

The ability to track conversions and run A/B tests has also been invaluable in optimizing my marketing strategy. TrustPulse has helped me boost engagement and sales on my website, all at a fraction of the cost of other social proof tools.

Kartik Ahuja, Digital Marketer, kartikahuja.com

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!