9 Proven Strategy to Skyrocket Your Instagram Post Engagement

In the dynamic world of Instagram, eight seasoned Content Creators and Digital Marketers reveal their secrets to boosting post engagement. From adopting a consistent, theme-based strategy to maintaining regular posting for engagement, discover the specific strategies that have made a significant impact on their Instagram success.

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!

Adopt a Consistent, Theme-Based Strategy

“No plan is the best plan.” When I heard this dialogue in the famous Oscar-winning movie ‘Parasite,’ I was immediately triggered as an online marketer.

Preplanning and strategies are everything for us! To increase the engagement of Instagram posts, I have adopted a consistent and theme-based posting strategy.

Over time, I have noticed that no matter what format of content we choose to post on Instagram, the key factor that leads to more engagement is performing a balancing act of feeding the algorithm and the end target audience. But this doesn’t mean you should not think about the type of content you are going to post.

Tailoring content to your niche is crucial. Take Teknikforce, for example. In the software development niche, our focus is on empowering small businesses. Posting about AI, marketing tips, and online business tricks has sparked meaningful engagement.

As for the format, flexibility is key. Currently, reels are Instagram’s golden ticket for engagement. Staying updated on industry trends, like AI and marketing developments, keeps our content fresh and relevant.

Remember, simplicity is key. By balancing algorithmic appeal with audience interests, you can boost engagement without overcomplicating things.

Taniya Dutta, Content Creator, TeknikForce

Incorporate Engaging Calls-to-Action

One effective strategy I’ve leveraged to spike the engagement on my Instagram posts is incorporating calls-to-action (CTAs) in my captions. Asking my followers a question works wonders! Whether it’s seeking their advice, inquiring about their preferred content, or simply asking for recommendations, this approach encourages them to interact more deeply with my posts.

I also prompt followers to click the link in my bio, which drives a bit of traffic and can increase interaction on other platforms, like my blog or email list.

Jennifer Pellerito, Travel Content Creator and Blogger, Jen on the Run

Utilize Instagram Analytics for Timing

I have seen success with paying close attention to Instagram analytics. Knowing specifically when our audience is active has been made possible thanks to Instagram’s detailed analytics breakdown. We are able to see the best days and specific hours to post Instagram content. This has led to increased engagement by our audience with our content.

Joy Nyargem, Founder and Chief Content Creator, Afrostylicity 

Humanize Your Brand on Instagram

One specific strategy I’ve employed to significantly increase the engagement rate of The Listing Real Estate Management’s Instagram is to take a personal approach and humanize our account. Instagram, primarily an entertainment app, should be utilized to increase brand sentiment and should not be taken too seriously.

Sharing personal but informative content such as behind-the-scenes footage of property management and Employee of the Month posts has enabled us to foster authentic connections with our target audience of Central Florida rental property owners. Showcasing the daily life of a property manager has resulted in a drastic increase in engagement and strengthened our network of followers.

Whether you’re a B2C or a B2B, it’s no secret that the person behind the Instagram posts is human. Although some companies may value a more traditional approach, we’ve entered an era where humanization and relatable content are key factors in sparking more engagement than ever before.

Sandra Quinn, Writer and Content Creator, The Listing Real Estate Management

Experiment with Storytelling and Hashtags

Increasing visibility and engagement rates of Instagram posts is a dynamic ballgame, one that requires constant revision and experimenting with various content and presentation approaches. I try to keep my posts real and mostly use a combination of textual and visual content to make them more engaging for a wider audience group. 

Using storytelling, humor, and wit as my basis for content creation, I strive to create more interactive and immersive content for my viewers to make it relatable. Strategically using relevant hashtags also increases my posts’ chances of being more visible and reachable to audiences. I pay special attention to using professional photography tools to produce high-quality visual content, like images and videos, which helps to grab more attention and also makes my videos and photos look more professional and free of errors.

There are many tricks and techniques that you can use to make your Instagram content more reachable to your target audience. The trick is to never settle for just one standard approach but to keep it dynamic and keep trying various techniques to keep it more interesting.

Kartik Ahuja, Digital Marketer, kartikahuja.com

Enhance Reels with Text Overlays

Reels are a really great engagement feature that Instagram does well. Your audience is much more likely to engage with your content when it’s given to them in a short and digestible fashion. 

However, what I have found can improve your engagement rates even more is text within the reel. Doing so makes your content more accessible to viewers who may be watching without sound or have hearing impairments. It also ensures that everyone can understand the message being conveyed, so there is also less confusion and a deeper understanding.

Text can be used to provide instructions, tips, or tutorials within the reel itself, which I have found makes it easier for your audience to understand complex concepts or follow step-by-step guides without having to rely solely on audio.

And ultimately, text overlays on Reels serve as captions or titles that grab viewers’ attention while scrolling through their feed. Bold, colorful, or creatively designed text can attract users to stop and watch the reel, versus simply having a textless video!

Danielle Hu, Founder, The Wanderlover

Create Organic Reels with Sensory Appeal

To help increase business-to-consumer engagement on Instagram for lifestyle content, I’ve found success with short, organic Reels that hone in on connecting personally with audiences through familiarity and sensory stimulation.

Here’s what this looks like: a strategy of creating video content with a strong point-of-view flavor that encourages viewers to realistically imagine themselves right there in the video—from experiencing the sights and sounds firsthand, to feeling like a relatable friend or expert is chatting directly to them without an agenda. 

Techniques can include opening with a catchy music hook and a visually striking shot, showing scenarios or locations that the viewer can relate to, incorporating movement in shots and a quick pace of sequences, unscripted interviews, and a warm, approachable finished product with more of a self-produced look and feel versus coming off as perfectly well-polished.

This strategy answers the question of “How do you create engaging content?” with bringing it back to basics: tapping into the five senses and cravings for connection that make us human.

Connie Smart, Content Writer and Creator, City of Edmonton

Curate Content to Current Trends

Understanding the current trend and curating content to suit that is a major “yay” strategy. Be it a giveaway offer or a greeting poster/video, staying relevant is key. Using high-performing hashtags and keywords for captions helps to optimize discoverability and engagement. Cross-promotions on social media platforms and creating shareable content amplify brand visibility across a wider audience.

Pavithra Desikan, Content creator, Social media marketing

Maintain Regular Posting for Engagement

Consistency is crucial for any social media platform. It builds recognition, fosters trust, and cultivates a loyal audience. By regularly posting high-quality content, you stay top-of-mind and establish yourself as a reliable source of information or entertainment. 

This consistency also allows me to build relationships with my followers through comments and interactions, ultimately driving engagement.

Daksha Chindarkar, Content Writer, Werqlabs

Want to get quoted in MarketerInterview.com content just like this? Apply to become a contributor today!